GLEEful Good Girls

Here I go, dipping my toes in the waters of blogosphere.  Although I am a reformed techno-phobe (when I was 21, a friend sat me down and insisted that I create an email account), I am not quite techno-geek and, well, I am reminded of the early morning swim practices of my youth…everyone else jumped in, and I entered the water inch by inch.  So, hooray to blogging.  It’s another inch into the brave new world of ____________.  

Who am I?  Well, a reading, grading papers, yoga-posing, cupcake baking kind of person who wants to write.  Of course, this is Mary Ann’s blog.  She is amazing.  If everyone had a Mary Ann, well, this world would be a better place.  She’s letting me blog with her, and maybe some of my students will read…get ideas about books, post to a “live” audience!  And, maybe I will make some new reading friends who have ideas for inspiring our younglings to read!  

Thus far, my 7th and 8th graders don’t feel too thrilled or impressed about the idea of their English teacher having a blog.  One kid tried to humor me by using powerful vocabulary (they know I love that): ” I am ecstatic,” he said. Unsupportive, ironic little buggers.  

Speaking of little buggers, how about “Glee”?  (I promise to work on transitions).  One of my 8th grade boys thinks it is the “most ridiculous show” on tv.  He’s a pretty cool guy and prefers “The Office.” I started watching “Glee” last season, finally caving to intense pressure from my 8th grade girls.  Usually I find it hard to commit to a weekly show, but thanks to Hulu and a husband who works late on Tuesdays, I’ve managed to be a faithful Gleek. My 8th grade girls and I enjoy discussing each episode: we are very critical of Mr. Shue — Will, grow up! — , love Mercedes just the way she is, think Kurt should get over it and revere Sue as the goddess of hair insults.  However, I was a little alarmed about The Power of Madonna episode.  Guess why…

Because of a personal vendetta against Madonna?  No.  Because Rachel’s negligee looked like something from 1950?  No.  Because the idea of discussing three plot strands in which three characters may or may not lose their virginity makes me feel uncomfortable?  Yes.  I know, I know…what about Quinn?  She is already pregnant.  Puck is a womanizer.  Evil brunette cheerleader is promiscuous.  What’s the difference?  Is it because Quinn, Puck and EBC are punished for their choices?  Maybe.  The prospect of Rachel losing her virginity to annoying guy, Jesse, from Vocal Adrenaline is frightening.  Aside from the fact that we (8th grade girls and I) think Jesse is snake, Rachel is a “good girl.”  And, I think that is what bothered me most.  Because, if I am honest, I wasn’t as concerned about Finn in a cheap motel with EBC or Mr. Shue and Kewpie Doll (Emma Pillsbury).  But, “good girls” having sex?  Noooooooo…!  I won’t add a spoiler, in case you want to see it on Hulu.  

My 8th grade girls (from now on referred to as Las Chicas) and I discussed the episode.  Las Chicas varied in their responses.  One advised others “not to watch with parents.”  Too cringe worthy.  Other Chicas felt like there was too much sex, and they especially don’t care about Mr. Shue. They just want more singing. But one Chica said that “Glee” is like real life.  Apparently, Jesse getting mad at Rachel is true to life.  According to La Chica, unlike 90210 — the characters on “Glee” make choices that are realistic. 

And this is the crux of why I like “Glee” — because the characters break into song, and yet the show is still described as “realistic” by the Las Chicas.  It’s funny and smart and true to life — for some more than others.  

This brings me back to my earlier confession — the good girl thinking about having sex.  Can she still be the good girl?  The type A, uber-motivated princess with two dads?  I know, I know — she can.  I teach middle school, a world of absolutes, of good and evil, black and white, right and wrong.  And that might be another reason they like “Glee”.  It presents the middle ground,the space between light and dark, a space some Las Chicas navigate already.


One Response

  1. […] GLEEful Good Girls […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: